about disability rights uk advisers benefits coalition on charging contact da disability benefits consortium home links membership policy and campaigns search shop site map skill website support da tax credits what's new

Conflicting decisions on the pca "sitting" test

Commissioner's decision CIB/1239/2004 , following the decision of Howker v. Secretary of State for Social Security stated that the description/descriptor for "sitting" used in the the personal capability assessment test was unlawful from 15 July 2004. The wording became as follows:

Sitting in an upright chair with a back but no arms

• Cannot sit comfortably - score 15
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than 10 minutes without having to move from the chair - score 15 
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than 30 minutes without having to move from the chair - score 7 
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than one hour without having to move from the chair - score 3

Note: This guidance never applied in Northern Ireland.

A later decision, CIB/3397/2004, has argued that this was not unlawful and guidance was issued stating that the wording of the test is now:

Sitting in an upright chair with a back but no arms

• Cannot sit comfortably - score 15
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than 10 minutes without having to move from the chair because the degree of discomfort makes it impossible to continue sitting - score 15 
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than 30 minutes without having to move from the chair because the degree of discomfort makes it impossible to continue sitting - score 7 
• Cannot sit comfortably for more than one hour without having to move from the chair because the degree of discomfort makes it impossible to continue sitting - score 3

Note: This wording also applies in Northern Ireland.

More information

• howker v. secretary of state for social security
• cib/1239/2004
• cib/3397/2004
• personal capability assessment physical descriptors and scores

back